Investigating the Microbial Indicators of Extracted Chubak Juice for Halva Tahini Preparation: Insight into Production Methods
Hamideh Kamali; PhD candidate 1, Fahimeh Teimouri; PhD *2, Sara Jambarsang; PhD 3, Abolfazl Paydar; BSc 2,4, Mahboubeh Shiranian; MSc3, Zahra Naderipour; MSc2 & Jalal Sadeghizadeh-Yazdi; PhD6
1 Department of Environmental Health Engineering, School of Public Health, Shahrekord University of Medical Sciences, Shahrekord, Iran; 2 Environmental Sciences and Technology Research Center, Department of Environmental Health Engineering, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran; 3 Center for Healthcare Data Modeling, Departments of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, School of public health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran; 4 Student Research Committee, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran.; 5 Department of Food Science and Technology, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran.
| ARTICLE INFO |
|
ABSTRACT |
| ORIGINAL ARTICLE |
Background: Extracted Chubak juice (Ab-chubak) is used for aeration, whitening, and increasing the consistency of Halva Tahini. This study investigated the most important microbiological quality parameters of Ab-chubak. Methods: Sampling of Ab-chubak was done from 100 Halva Tahini units (manual and boiling preparation methods) in Ardakan city. The serial dilution and pour plate method on Sabouraud Dextrose Agar were used for fungal detection, as this medium is primarily employed for the selective cultivation of yeasts and molds, and additionally for determining the microbial contamination in food. Total coliforms (TC) and Fecal coliforms (FC) were identified by most probable number (MPN) method. Results: Yeast frequencies were 31.6% and 48.8% in the manual and boiling of Ab-chubak production methods. Similarly, the results of Geotrichum and Aspergillus fungi were 31.6% and 10% in manual methods, respectively, whereas in the secondary method, Geotrichum had frequency of 11.6%, and Aspergillus was not detected. TC were 392.52 and 508.25 MPN/100 ml in Ab-chubak prepared in manual and boiling methods, while FC coliforms were 308.31 and 434.55 MPN/100 ml in the mentioned samples, respectively. The results indicated a significant difference in mean number of fungal colonies between two Ab-chubak preparation methods (P=0.04). Also, the results showed a significant difference (P=0.002) in the morphology of the investigated fungi in two Ab-chubak preparation methods. Conclusion: The average of bacterial indicators was similar in two Ab-chubak preparation methods. However, the presence of fungal species such as Aspergillus was confirmed, which can be considered as an opportunistic pathogen. |
Article history:
Received: 2 Jan 2025
Revised: 20apr 2025
Accepted: 21 May 2025 |
*Corresponding author:
f.teimouri@ssu.ac.ir
Department of Environmental Health Engineering, School of Public Health, Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, Yazd, Iran.
Postal code: 8915173160
Tel: +98 35 31492151 |
Keywords:
Food safety;
Fungal contamination; Bacterial contamination; Hlva tahini. |
Introduction
As shown in Figure 2; the prevalence of Geotrichum, Penicilium, and Aspergillus was 31.6, 26.3 and 10.5%, in the manual method, while Geotrichum and Penicilium were found at a prevalence of 11.6 and 9.3% in boiling methods. However, Aspergillus was not detected in Ab-chubak prepared by the last method. Overall, manual method showed a higher prevalence of Geotrichum, Penicillium, and Aspergillus compared to boiling method, whereas yeasts were more prevalent in boiling method. The results of chi-square test also showed a significant difference (P=0.002). In other words, the morphology of investigated fungi differed between two Ab-chubak preparation methods.
Total and fecal coliforms enumeration
Table 3 shows the average total and fecal coliforms in Ab-chubak produced using boiling and manual methods.
| Table 3. Total and Fecal coliforms in Ab-chubak samples (MPN/100 ml). |
|
| Bacterial indicator |
Mean±SD |
Min |
Max |
Total coliform
Manual |
392.52±1065.68 |
0 |
3600 |
| Boiling |
508.25±1053.62 |
0 |
3700 |
Fecal coliform
Manual |
308.31±878.24 |
0 |
3600 |
| Boiling |
434.55±899.48 |
0 |
3200 |
According to Table 3, the mean of total coliform in manual and boiling preparation methods were 392.52±1065.68 and 508.25±1053.62 MPN/100 ml, respectively. Similarly, fecal coliform counts were 308.31±878.24 and 434.55±899.48 MPN/100 ml, respectively. However, results of statistical analysis using Mann-Whitney test indicated that mean values of these two parameters (P=0.94 for TC and 0.66 for FC) did not differ significantly between two Ab-chubak preparation methods.
Discussion
Analysis of microorganisms gives vital data on cleanliness of food, its expiration date, and possible health hazards (Lima et al., 2023). Detecting pathogens, spoilage microbes, and other contaminants in complicated food matrices is crucial (Ferone et al., 2020). This study examined microbial parameters in Tahini production units and identified three different types of yeast fungi including yeast, Aspergillus, Geotrichum, and Penicillium. This is consistent with a study conducted by Mahdian Yazdi et al. on Halva Tahini, which reported that among 60 samples (halva ardeh), three were contaminated with molds, one with yeast, four with Escherichia coli, and one with Enterobacteriaceae (Yazdi et al., 2018).The results of fungal counts indicated that 31.6% of manually prepared samples were contaminated with yeast, whereas 48.8% of samples prepared by boiling showed yeast contamination. Similar results were obtained from conducted studies by Sengun et al. and Kotzekidou; 1.5×102 and 4.9×103 CFU/g, respectively (Kotzekidou, 1998, Sengun et al., 2005). Additionally, a study by Kilci et al. on various types of Halva Tahini revealed that microbiological analyses for yeast and mold contamination showed an average of 10 CFU/g, 90 CFU/g in hazelnut Halva Tahini, 45 CFU/g in carob Halva Tahini, and 25 CFU/g in vanilla Halva Tahini (Kilci and Çetin, 2022).
This difference may be attributed to characteristics of yeasts, such as their mesophilic and thermophilic properties, which make them more resistant compared to other fungi like molds. Additionally, aerobic conditions may inhibit mold growth, which could explain the higher prevalence of yeasts in boiling method compared to manual method (Sengun et al., 2005). Another reason for the identification of yeast in boiling samples could be related to the storage of Ab-chubak in refrigerator after boiling method. This may allow for the transfer of yeast contamination through the air inside the refrigerator.
Regarding Geotrichum and Aspergillus fungi, results indicated that their prevalence in manual samples was 31.6% and 10.5%, respectively, whereas, in boiling method, Geotrichum was present at 11.6% and Aspergillus was not detected. Manual method showed a higher prevalence of Geotrichum, Penicillium, and Aspergillus compared to boiling method, while yeasts were more prevalent.
In the study by Kahraman on Halva Tahini samples, it was found that 36.66% of samples had poor quality based on microbiological and chemical standards recommended by Turkish Food Codex. The microbiological quality criteria included aerobic bacteria, Staphylococcus aureus, coliforms, Escherichia coli, molds, yeasts, Salmonella species, and staphylococcal enterotoxins. Chemical quality criteria included sesame oil, protein, moisture, ash content, acidity, total sugar content, and peroxide levels. The predominant level of contamination was 10.38% for molds, which was lower than the contamination level for yeasts at 38.20%. This could be attributed to factors such as inadequate hygiene of raw materials, production area, and sample storage conditions (Kahraman et al., 2010).
In this study, the mean of number of TC was 392.52±1065.68 and 508.25±1053.62 MPN/100 ml for manual and boiling methods, respectively. Additionally, the number of FC in mentioned samples was 308.31±878.24 and 434.55±899.48 MPN/100 ml, respectively. In other words, TC and FC counts were approximately similar in two methods, with no significant differences. Given the relatively long storage duration, one reason for the higher coliform counts could be attributed to the storage of these samples in the refrigerator after boiling. This storage method may allow for the transfer of coliform contamination through secondary contamination. Another reason could be related to secondary contamination via human preparation or the preserved dishes that transferred bacterial contamination.
Most similar studies have mentioned that Halva may become contaminated with various microorganisms due to direct or indirect contact with external sources of contamination during production (Abu-Jdayil et al., 2002). the results of the present study, indicate that such contamination may result from the microbial flora of raw materials, such as Ab-chubak, insufficient thermal treatment, and inadequate personal hygiene during production (Aydin and Başaran, 2018).
In a study conducted by Karam et al. multiple outbreaks of S. bovismorbificans, S. Montevideo, and S. Mbandaka infection were related to Tahini consumption that were reported in the United States. Moreover, Escherichia coli was found in 17% of Tahini samples in Lebanon (Karam, 2010).
In a study conducted by Aydın et al. on Tahini halva samples, the results showed that coliforms and Escherichia coli were found at acceptable levels (28 MPN/g) (Aydin and Başaran, 2018). Sengun et al. reported coliforms levels of 41 CFU/g, and Kotzekidou reported 30 CFU/g, which are consistent with the findings of the present study regarding the identification of coliforms and Escherichia coli (Kotzekidou, 1998, Sengun et al., 2005).
In a study conducted by Eshaghi on Halva Tahini in Yazd and Ardakan, it was found that 8.3% of Halva Tahini samples from Ardakan and 12.5% of samples from Yazd were contaminated with Escherichia coli (Eshaghi, 2010). Since the presence of Escherichia coli in food indicates significant fecal contamination, inadequate personal hygiene may be a significant factor contributing to Escherichia coli contamination in Halva (Namiki, 1995). However, the results of studies conducted on Halva Tahini are promising, in the sense that the process of preparing Halva Tahini can reduce the bacterial indicators identified in Abchoubak, but it is still recommended to monitor this product regarding fungal surveillance.
Despite valuable findings of this study, a few limitations should be acknowledged. Molecular identification and mycotoxin analysis were notable limitations of this study, and their investigation is recommended for future research.
Conclusion
The present study underscores the need for microbiological quality control in Ab-chubak, a key additive in Halva Tahini production. The findings highlighted the presence of opportunistic fungal species and fecal coliforms, indicating potential health risks. Given the absence of regulatory standards for Ab-chubak, establishing effective contamination control measures is crucial. Implementing strict hygiene protocols, heat treatments, and improved monitoring practices across production and distribution can significantly reduce microbial contamination. These measurements will enhance food safety, minimize health risks, and ensure the hygienic quality of Ab-chubak in food applications.
Acknowledgment
The authors thank Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences for supporting the current research (Code number: 14627).
Authors' contributions
Design study was conducted by Teimouri F, Sadeghizadeh-Yazdi J. Experimentations were performed by Paydar A, Shiranian M, Naderipour Z. Data analysis was conducted by Jambarsang S. The draft manuscript was written by Kamali H and Teimouri F. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Conflict of interest
No potential conflict of interest is reported by the author(s).
Funding
No specific funding was used to do this.
References
Abu-Jdayil B, Al-Malah K & Asoud H 2002. Rheological characterization of milled sesame (tehineh). Food hydrocolloids. 16 (1): 55-61.
Ajobiewe H 2021. Parasitological and fungal assessment of fresh cow milk obtained from five herds in Karshi, FCT Nigeria. SAS journal of medicine. 9: 395-406.
Akbarian MJ & Babaei A 2019. Investigating of antifungal activity of polylactic acid film containing iron nanoparticles in a food system. Iranian journal of medical microbiology 12 (5): 338-347.
Alpaslan M & Hayta M 2002. Rheological and sensory properties of pekmez (grape molasses)/tahin (sesame paste) blends. Journal of food engineering. 54 (1): 89-93.
Arslan E, Yener ME & Esin A 2005. Rheological characterization of tahin/pekmez (sesame paste/concentrated grape juice) blends. Journal of food engineering. 69 (2): 167-172.
Aydin F & Başaran B 2018. Microbiological risks related with raw materials in halva production and detection of microbiological critical control points. Akademik Gıda. 16 (1): 42-50.
Azadbakht M, Ziaee H, Yousefi Z, Shabankhani B & Mehralian A 2005. Evaluation of Chubak aqueous extract in parasite decontamination on vegetables and comparison with commercial detergent in Sari. Journal of medicinal plants. 4 (15): 51-58.
Elgarhi H-EM, Abu-Elhebal HM, Elewa NAH & Galal EA 2020. Morphological characteristics of fungi species isolated from dairy products in Fayoum governorate. Egyptian journal of food science. 48 (1): 173-179.
Eshaghi m 2010. Identification and determination of Entrobacteriaceae and Escherichia Coli bacterial contamination of Tahini Halva in Ardakan and Yazd cities. Iranian journal of biological sciences. 5 (2): 49-54.
Ferone M, Gowen A, Fanning S & Scannell AG 2020. Microbial detection and identification methods: Bench top assays to omics approaches. Comprehensive reviews in food science and food safety. 19 (6): 3106-3129.
Frances EC, Johnson OO & Frances ME 2021. Isolation and identification of microorganisms in wine produced from red muscat grapes. Asian journal of plant and soil sciences. 6 (3): 21-27.
Gaidi G, Miyamoto T, Ramezani M & Lacaille-Dubois M-A 2004. Glandulosides A- D, Triterpene Saponins from Acanthophyllum glandulosum. Journal of natural products. 67 (7): 1114-1118.
Güçlü-Üstündağ Ö & Mazza G 2007. Saponins: properties, applications and processing. Critical reviews in food science and nutrition. 47 (3): 231-258.
Henao OL, Scallan E, Mahon B & Hoekstra RM 2010. Methods for monitoring trends in the incidence of foodborne diseases: Foodborne diseases active surveillance network 1996–2008. Foodborne pathogens and disease. 7 (11): 1421-1426.
Hossini tabatabaei F, karajhian H & karajhian R 2017. Study of rheological properties of ketchup sauce containing hydrocloidal extract of Chubak plant. Journal of innovation in food science and technology. 2 (9): 61-76.
Institute of Standards and Industrial Research of Iran 2008. Microbiology of Food and Animal Feed - Comprehensive Method for Identification and Enumeration of Coliforms Most Probable Number (MPN) Method.
Institute of Standards and Industrial Research of Iran 2021. Microbiology of food and animal feeding stuffs-Detection and enumeration of presumptive Escherichia coli-Most probable number technique.
Iranian National Standardization Organization 2013. Microbioligy of food and animal feeding stuffs-enumeration of Yeast and mould-Colony count techni in products with water activity Less than or equal to 0.60.
Kahraman T, Issa G, Ozmen G & Buyukunal S 2010. Microbiological and chemical quality of tahini halva. British food journal. 112 (6): 608-616.
Karam LA 2010. The Determination and Validation of Microbial Criteria for Tahini and Halawi Products. American University of Beirut, Department of Nutrition and Food Sciences.
Kilci Z & Çetin RU 2022. Determination of chemical and microbiological quality in commercial Tahini Halva samples. Turkish journal of agriculture-food science and technology. 10: 2982-2987.
Kotzekidou P 1998. Microbial stability and fate of Salmonella Enteritidis in halva, a low-moisture confection. Journal of food protection. 61 (2): 181-185.
Lima EEL, et al. 2023. The importance of microbiological analysis in food: A importância das análises microbiológicas em alimentos. Concilium. 23 (5): 74-85.
Machin D, Campbell MJ, Tan SB & Tan SH 2011. Sample size tables for clinical studies. John Wiley & Sons.
Mahasti Shotorbani P & Momeninejad M 2019. Designing a health food control management model for Kohgiluyeh and Boyerahmad province. Armaghane danesh. 24 (1): 122-140.
Mossel D & Struijk C 1995. Escherichia coli, other Enterobacteriaceae and additional indicators as markers of microbiologic quality of food: advantages and limitations. Microbiologia. 11 (1): 75-90.
Namiki M 1995. The chemistry and physiological functions of sesame. Food reviews international. 11 (2): 281-329.
Samson RA 2011. Ecology and general characteristics of indoor fungi. In Fundamentals of mold growth in indoor environments and strategies for healthy living (ed. R. Samson), pp. 101-116. Wageningen Academic.
Sengun IY, Hancioglu O & Karapinar M 2005. Microbiological profile of helva sold at retail markets in Izmir city and the survival of Staphylococcus aureus in this product. Food control. 16 (10): 840-844.
Sezgin AC & Artik N 2010. Determination of saponin content in Turkish tahini halvah by using HPLC. Advance journal of food science and technology. 2 (2): 109-115.
Shaker Ardakani A, Shahdi M & Kabir G 2012. Evaluation and comparison of traditional and industrial Halva Ardeh production in Iran. In The 18th National Congress of Food Industries.
Sholichah A, Yulistiani R, Sarofa U & Raharjo D 2022. Bacterial contamination on meatballs sold in traditional markets PD Surya market in east Surabaya region causes a decline in people's income. Budapest international research and critics institute journal 5(4): 31039-31052.
Twedt RM & Boutin BK 1979. Potential public health significance of non-Escherichia coli coliforms in food. Journal of food protection. 42 (2): 161-163.
Urooj S, Mirani ZA & Naz S 2018. Impact of seasonal variations on bacterial, yeast and mold’s count in drinking water collected from Karachi Pakistan. PSM Microbiol. 3 (1): 37-42.
Yazdi RM, Nodushan SM & Mahmoodabadi RSR 2018. Microbial contamination of Tahini, flavored Tahini and Halva in Yazd, Iran. 2017. Iranian journal of infectious diseases. 23 (81): 17-20.